Pre-purchase a pie and vanilla pint combo and save $5! Available for pick up at Caffè Panna pop-up event days only. 

A soft and creamy custard; earthy with sweet vanilla undertones. Flecked throughout with toasted ground black sesame and topped with a sprinkling of whole seeds.

Lightly toasted, buttery pecans, blended with a classic (but not too sweet) pecan pie style custard, atop a decadent layer of dark chocolate ganache. This is pecan pie on a whole new level.

Smooth and rich chocolate custard made with cocoa powder - think chocolate pudding pie! Pairs perfectly with homemade whipped cream. 

Light, creamy custard made with Variety Coffee Roasters Cold Brew coffee. Smooth, complex, and full-bodied with a slightly sweet finish.

A Four & Twenty Blackbirds original creation, addictive and unique. Often imitated, never duplicated! Sweet, fragrant honey custard finished with a touch of flake sea salt for a perfect balance. A cult favorite!

A Four & Twenty Blackbirds classic and our most popular pie. We start with a mix of sweet and tart apples sourced from the Hudson Valley of NY, tossed in a spice blend that includes Angostura bitters, and combined with our homemade caramel sauce. Finished with a light sprinkle of flake sea salt for a perfectly balanced apple pie.

Rich green tea custard made with Ippodo matcha imported from Japan.  Full bodied green tea flavor balanced out by decadently smooth and slightly sweet custard.

A silken smooth custard that has the perfect lemon flavor; balancing tangy, sweetness, and creamy - a notch above meringue. Also tastes great when chilled.

A brown sugar custard with a layer of dark chocolate ganache on the bottom, filled with toasty oats. Like a deliciously gooey oatmeal chocolate chip cookie, in pie form.     

A luscious blend of locally grown sweet and tart apples, with warm notes of vanilla and nutty browned butter, topped with our signature buttery streusel.

Add a personalized handwritten note with your pie or pastry delivery. Please add your message to the notes box on the cart page before proceeding to checkout - we will add to it your special delivery!

Roasted peanuts top a brown sugar custard flecked with coconut, with dark chocolate ganache layered underneath, all in our signature all-butter pie crust. Like a gooey nutty candy bar.