To pre-order for the week of Thanksgiving (Sunday, 11/22 - Thursday, 11/26), please view our Thanksgiving 2026 menu. 

Please note, local delivery in NYC the week of Thanksgiving is sold out. 

Click here to view our Thanksgiving Menu. Every year, we offer four beloved flavors:

• Salted Caramel Apple
• Brown Butter Pumpkin
• Salty Honey
• Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan

Each pie is 10 inches and yields 8-10 slices. Pies are $46 each.

In addition to our Gowanus pie shop, we have the following pickup locations available the week of Thanksgiving: 

The Country Table in Greenwich, CT on Tuesday, 11/24 from 7 am to 4 pm. 

Wild East Brewing Co in Gowanus. Monday, 11/23 - Wednesday, 11/25 from 2 pm to 8 pm.

Please make sure to select your preferred pickup location and date at checkout! 

We highly recommend pre-ordering to ensure you get exactly what you want!

We will have a limited supply of pies available on a first-come, first-served basis each day of Thanksgiving week (Sunday, 11/22 - Thursday, 11/26) during business hours at our Gowanus pie shop. Arrive early for the best chance of getting one!

THANKSGIVING HOURS: 

Sunday, 11/22: 10 AM - 7 PM

Monday, 11/23: 8 AM - 7 PM

Tuesday, 11/24: 8 AM - 7 PM

Wednesday, 11/25: 8 AM - 7 PM

Thursday, 11/26: 8 AM - 3 PM (Thanksgiving)

Please note, we close at 3 pm on Thanksgiving day! 

All sales are final. Because of the volume of Thanksgiving pie orders we receive, we cannot accommodate changes to placed orders, including to pick up days or location.
Thank you for understanding.

Pies do not need to be refrigerated immediately, but should be refrigerated if not eaten or served within 24 hours of purchase.

Pies can be refrigerated in the box and will last up to 5 days. Bring to room temperature a few hours before serving. Our pies are also delicious served chilled!

For more information on freezing or reheating pies, please visit our Storage & Reheating Instructions page. 

PLEASE NOTE: Local delivery in NYC the week of Thanksgiving is sold out! 

If you placed an order for delivery during our pre-sale, please review the following policies: 

All deliveries are fulfilled through our trusted third-party delivery partner, between 9 am - 4 pm. 

Mobile number required: The phone number you provide when placing an order will be used for delivery and text tracking updates. To ensure the recipient receives these updates, please make sure it is a mobile number. The phone number you provided will be in your confirmation email—if you need to update it after placing an order, simply reply to the confirmation email. 

Recipient must be contactable: The recipient must be contactable at the provided phone number. We strongly recommend letting gift recipients know a delivery is coming.

If the recipient is unreachable: When possible, orders may be left with building reception or in a safe spot inside the building. Otherwise, a redelivery fee will apply.

Drivers are given the following instructions: 'Call the recipient when you arrive. Items can be left with doorman (if available) if unable to contact recipient. DO NOT leave items unattended.' 

Make sure to pick up your pies on the day you selected when you placed the order. Pies can be picked up anytime during business hours. 

Please bring your confirmation number with you. Orders not claimed on their pickup date are considered forfeited.  

Please note, we close at 3 pm on Thanksgiving day!