Choose the Order Pie link on our homepage menu and choose one of the options from the list.

For in-store pickup, or next day local delivery in the NYC Metropolitan area (order must be placed by 12noon), choose Store Pickup + Local Delivery.

For same day delivery via Grubhub or Caviar in Brooklyn only, choose the link closest to your Brooklyn neighborhood - sorry this service is not available city-wide.

For Nationwide Shipping via Goldbelly, choose Nationwide Shipping.

We do NOT slice whole pies that have been pre-ordered, as things tend to get messy during transport after a pie is sliced. Besides, its more fun to slice the pie yourself into the size you'd like.

We are counter service establishments and we do not take reservations during regular business hours. If you are interested in booking one of our spaces for a private event, please fill out the form on our Weddings + Catering + Special Events page and someone from our team will get back to you!

You may call the shop and ask to speak to one of our managers 718-499-2917, or fill out the form on our Weddings + Catering + Special Events page.

Check out our Weddings + Catering + Special Events page on this site for more information!

Please send an email to with your request.