THANKSGIVING PRE-ORDERS ARE NOW SOLD OUT!

Matcha Custard
$45.00
Rich green tea custard made with Ippodo matcha imported from Japan.  Full bodied green tea flavor balanced out by decadently smooth and slightly sweet custard.

Quantity:

Orders must be placed by 12:00pm for next day pickup or delivery.

MONDAY ORDERS REQUIRE 48 HOUR LEAD TIME

Orders placed after 12:00pm will be available in 2 days.

Pies are 10" and typically serve 8-10

Please note, all of our pies are made fresh to order, just for you! Pie orders that are not picked up on the reserved date are considered forfeited and will not be refunded. All sales are final.

More Pies

Bittersweet chocolate pecan whole pie

Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan

$45.00
Liquid error (snippets/product-grid-item line 252): invalid integer
Chocolate Chess

Chocolate Chess

$45.00
Liquid error (snippets/product-grid-item line 252): invalid integer
Salty Honey pie by Four & Twenty Blackbirds NYC New York City pie shop

Salty Honey®

$45.00
Liquid error (snippets/product-grid-item line 252): invalid integer
salted caramel apple pie with lattice top

Salted Caramel Apple

$45.00
Liquid error (snippets/product-grid-item line 252): invalid integer
Brown Butter Pumpkin

Brown Butter Pumpkin

$45.00
Liquid error (snippets/product-grid-item line 252): invalid integer
Lemon Chess

Lemon Chess

$45.00
Liquid error (snippets/product-grid-item line 252): invalid integer
Black Bottom Oat

Black Bottom Oat

$45.00
Liquid error (snippets/product-grid-item line 252): invalid integer
Brown Butter Apple Streusel

Brown Butter Apple Streusel

$45.00
Liquid error (snippets/product-grid-item line 252): invalid integer
Note card front reading 'Pie For You' with Four & Twenty Blackbirds nyc pie shop logo

Handwritten Card [N/A during Holiday periods]

$3.00
Liquid error (snippets/product-grid-item line 252): invalid integer